Thx for the great suggestions, everyone!
We were down for the weekend Fri-Sun and had a fab time!
Checked out Wrecked at the Reef a few times (loved it! we even played pool and ping pong, but I wish they had shuffle board) and, of course, JJJJ (who could miss that!), but still need to ck out Barra Vieja, Changos, The Hideaway and Sr Amigos, although we decided to pass on Gau Gaus, so maybe next trip (you guys really crack me up) ;-).
Also, hit up the Mexican Denny's (aka Sombrero on Calle 13) for some pretty good eats at 2:30 in the morning after the RCPM concert and lived to tell about it! Met some great folks there, too, who had a sail boat at the docks!
All in all it was a wonderful trip and we are really looking forward to going back!
Thanks again for all the wonderful recommendations and safe travels!
Salud!